Skip to content

Xavier Kain is all about attention to detail. This site hides 7 secrets.

    SEO, Redesign16 November 2026 3 min read

    Website redesign: the checklist to keep your search rankings.

    A website's old pages linked one by one to its new pages by redirects

    A redesign loses traffic when old addresses disappear without a redirect, when content that ranked is deleted or cut down, or when the new site blocks crawlers by mistake. All three are avoidable with a simple method: take inventory before, redirect during, check after.

    Here is the checklist I follow, in order. It applies to a redesign on the same domain as well as to a CMS change, for example from Wix to WordPress.

    Before the redesign: take inventory.

    You cannot protect what you have not listed. Before touching the design, you need to know which pages exist and which ones bring traffic.

    • List every URL: current sitemap, a crawler export, pages indexed in Google Search Console.
    • Find the pages that matter: in Search Console's Performance report, sort pages by clicks and impressions over the last 12 months.
    • Note inbound links: pages cited by other websites must keep a destination.
    • Save the tags: title, meta description and H1 of the important pages, to compare after launch.

    The most expensive mistake

    Deleting or shortening content that ranked because it "doesn't fit" the new mock-up. The new design must make room for the content that performs, not the other way round.

    During: the 301 redirect plan.

    Every old address whose URL changes must redirect, with a 301, to the closest new page by topic. That is what passes the value built up by the old page to the new one.

    Good and bad redirects
    SituationDoAvoid
    The page still exists at another address301 to its new addressLeaving the old address as a 404
    The page is merged with another301 to the page that takes over its content301 to the home page
    The page is removed with no equivalentA deliberate 404 or 410Redirecting everything to the home page
    Old address already redirectedPoint straight to the final destinationChains of successive redirects

    The plan is prepared in a two-column sheet, old and new URL, then tested before launch. On this website, for example, old .html addresses redirect with a 301 to addresses without the extension, and retired articles redirect to the guide that covers the same topic.

    During: check the new site before opening it.

    • robots.txt and noindex tags: staging sites are often blocked to crawlers. That block must not reach production.
    • Canonical tags: each page points to its own final address, not to the staging address.
    • Titles and descriptions: keep the ones that worked, or improve them, but never leave them empty or duplicated.
    • Internal links: they point to the new addresses, not to redirects.
    • Languages: on a multilingual site, hreflang tags follow the new addresses.

    After launch: monitor for several weeks.

    • Submit the new sitemap in Google Search Console.
    • Test a sample of old addresses: each one must return 301 then 200, in a single hop.
    • Watch Search Console's Pages report: a rise in 404 errors means a forgotten redirect.
    • Compare clicks and impressions of the important pages with the period before.
    • Keep redirects in place for the long term, at least a year, and ideally as long as links point to the old addresses.

    A temporary dip is normal

    Google has to recrawl the site and process the redirects. Fluctuations in the first weeks are expected; a lasting drop almost always points to a missing redirect or deleted content.

    Going further.

    To decide whether to redesign and on what budget, see the website redesign guide. If you are changing CMS, a migration to WordPress follows exactly this method.

    FAQ — Redesign and SEO.

    How long should you keep 301 redirects after a redesign?

    Google recommends keeping them for at least a year. In practice, it is better to leave them in place as long as other websites or old bookmarks point to the old addresses: they cost almost nothing to keep.

    Should deleted pages redirect to the home page?

    No. A redirect to an unrelated page is treated as a page not found. Redirect to the page covering the same topic; if there is none, return a 404 or 410.

    Does changing CMS hurt your SEO?

    Not in itself. Traffic is lost through addresses that change without redirects, deleted content and lost tags. A migration from Wix or another CMS to WordPress goes well when the inventory and redirect plan are done first.

    Sources.

    Planning a redesign?

    I prepare the inventory and redirect plan before touching the design, so your traffic follows the new site.