A redesign loses traffic when old addresses disappear without a redirect, when content that ranked is deleted or cut down, or when the new site blocks crawlers by mistake. All three are avoidable with a simple method: take inventory before, redirect during, check after.
Here is the checklist I follow, in order. It applies to a redesign on the same domain as well as to a CMS change, for example from Wix to WordPress.
Before the redesign: take inventory.
You cannot protect what you have not listed. Before touching the design, you need to know which pages exist and which ones bring traffic.
- List every URL: current sitemap, a crawler export, pages indexed in Google Search Console.
- Find the pages that matter: in Search Console's Performance report, sort pages by clicks and impressions over the last 12 months.
- Note inbound links: pages cited by other websites must keep a destination.
- Save the tags: title, meta description and H1 of the important pages, to compare after launch.
The most expensive mistake
Deleting or shortening content that ranked because it "doesn't fit" the new mock-up. The new design must make room for the content that performs, not the other way round.
During: the 301 redirect plan.
Every old address whose URL changes must redirect, with a 301, to the closest new page by topic. That is what passes the value built up by the old page to the new one.
| Situation | Do | Avoid |
|---|---|---|
| The page still exists at another address | 301 to its new address | Leaving the old address as a 404 |
| The page is merged with another | 301 to the page that takes over its content | 301 to the home page |
| The page is removed with no equivalent | A deliberate 404 or 410 | Redirecting everything to the home page |
| Old address already redirected | Point straight to the final destination | Chains of successive redirects |
The plan is prepared in a two-column sheet, old and new URL, then tested before launch. On this website, for example, old .html addresses redirect with a 301 to addresses without the extension, and retired articles redirect to the guide that covers the same topic.
During: check the new site before opening it.
- robots.txt and noindex tags: staging sites are often blocked to crawlers. That block must not reach production.
- Canonical tags: each page points to its own final address, not to the staging address.
- Titles and descriptions: keep the ones that worked, or improve them, but never leave them empty or duplicated.
- Internal links: they point to the new addresses, not to redirects.
- Languages: on a multilingual site, hreflang tags follow the new addresses.
After launch: monitor for several weeks.
- Submit the new sitemap in Google Search Console.
- Test a sample of old addresses: each one must return 301 then 200, in a single hop.
- Watch Search Console's Pages report: a rise in 404 errors means a forgotten redirect.
- Compare clicks and impressions of the important pages with the period before.
- Keep redirects in place for the long term, at least a year, and ideally as long as links point to the old addresses.
A temporary dip is normal
Google has to recrawl the site and process the redirects. Fluctuations in the first weeks are expected; a lasting drop almost always points to a missing redirect or deleted content.
Going further.
To decide whether to redesign and on what budget, see the website redesign guide. If you are changing CMS, a migration to WordPress follows exactly this method.
FAQ — Redesign and SEO.
How long should you keep 301 redirects after a redesign?
Google recommends keeping them for at least a year. In practice, it is better to leave them in place as long as other websites or old bookmarks point to the old addresses: they cost almost nothing to keep.
Should deleted pages redirect to the home page?
No. A redirect to an unrelated page is treated as a page not found. Redirect to the page covering the same topic; if there is none, return a 404 or 410.
Does changing CMS hurt your SEO?
Not in itself. Traffic is lost through addresses that change without redirects, deleted content and lost tags. A migration from Wix or another CMS to WordPress goes well when the inventory and redirect plan are done first.
Sources.
- Google Search Central — Site moves with URL changes — Google's recommended migration method
- Google Search Central — Redirects and Google Search — redirect types and how long to keep them
- Search Console Help — Page indexing report — tracking 404 errors after launch

